top of page
Search

The Math of the Alaska Senate Race: Why Trump's "Spoiler" Allegation Collapses Under Ranked-Choice Voting

1 day ago
7 min read
Even if 100% of minor-candidate votes are hypothetically credited to Sen. Dan S. Sullivan, he still trails Mary Peltola by 559 votes (left). In actual ranked-choice tabulation, minor-candidate second choices split and exhaust, leaving Peltola with a decisive ~10,300-vote victory (right)
Even if 100% of minor-candidate votes are hypothetically credited to Sen. Dan S. Sullivan, he still trails Mary Peltola by 559 votes (left). In actual ranked-choice tabulation, minor-candidate second choices split and exhaust, leaving Peltola with a decisive ~10,300-vote victory (right)


Standing before reporters on the White House South Lawn on the morning of November 16, 2026, Donald Trump offered a blunt assessment of the unresolved Alaska U.S. Senate election. Pressing his case before departing for an overseas trip to Asia with an Anchorage refueling stop, Trump claimed that incumbent Republican Senator Dan S. Sullivan was being deprived of victory by a deliberate ballot-splitting maneuver engineered by political opponents.

Trump singled out the two minor candidates on the ballot—undeclared candidate Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. and Republican Gerald L. Heikes—calling them "fake candidates" inserted to siphon conservative support:


"They put in two fake candidates, not one. And if you add them up, Dan Sullivan wins. But they put in two fake candidates. Add them up, Dan Sullivan wins. Terrible."


Trump’s complaint invokes one of the oldest and most destructive dynamics in American politics: the classic spoiler effect. In standard plurality voting systems, when an ideological majority divides its support across multiple similar candidates, an opposing candidate can capture the seat with a mere plurality of the vote. Yet, when subjected to elementary arithmetic and the mechanics of Alaska’s voter-approved ranked-choice voting (RCV) system, Trump’s claim collapses on two independent fronts: the raw vote totals make a direct flip mathematically impossible, and the ranked-choice ballot transfer records prove that minor-candidate voters did not uniformly prefer the incumbent.


1. The Starting Baseline: Current Standings in Alaska's Senate Contest

According to official counts published by the Alaska Division of Elections and verified by the Associated Press, with approximately 97% of ballots tallied, the first-choice votes divide among the four candidates as follows:


Candidate

Party / Affiliation

First-Choice Votes

Vote Share (%)

Mary Peltola

Democratic

140,637

~50.1% of 2-party / ~48.4% overall

Dan S. Sullivan (Incumbent)

Republican

129,424

~44.5%

Gerald L. Heikes

Republican

6,002

~2.1%

Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.

Undeclared

4,652

~1.6%

Total First-Choice Tally

—

280,715

100.0%


Because frontrunner Mary Peltola holds a substantial plurality but remains just shy of the 50.0% plus one vote required to win outright on Election Night, Alaska’s election law mandates an instant-runoff tabulation. Under state statutory deadlines, election officials wait until the fifteenth day after Election Day—Wednesday, November 18, 2026—to allow all validly postmarked overseas, military, and absentee ballots to arrive and be verified before tabulating ranked preferences.


2. The Arithmetic Fallacy: Even 100% Vote-Dumping Leaves the Incumbent Trailing

The most glaring flaw in Trump’s narrative is that his proposed calculation fails on simple addition. Even if one adopts the extreme, unrealistic premise that every single citizen who voted for Gerald L. Heikes and Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. was an incumbent supporter whose vote was "stolen," Senator Dan S. Sullivan still does not overtake Mary Peltola.


Summing the incumbent's tally with the entire first-choice vote volume of both minor candidates produces:


129,424 (Sen. Sullivan) + 6,002 (Heikes)} + 4,652 (Sullivan Jr.)} = 140,078 votes


Comparing that theoretical ceiling directly against Mary Peltola’s first-choice baseline reveals:


140,637 (Peltola) - 140,078 (Combined Three) = 559 votes


Mary Peltola holds an outright lead of 559 votes over all three of her opponents combined. Therefore, even under a hypothetical first-past-the-post ruleset where every third-party and independent vote is credited to the incumbent, Dan S. Sullivan does not win.


3. How Ranked-Choice Voting Structurally Neutralizes the "Spoiler Trap"

To understand why Trump’s argument fails conceptually, one must examine how voting systems manage multi-candidate fields. In traditional plurality elections, the "spoiler effect" is a real structural defect. As demonstrated during the 2000 presidential election in Florida, George W. Bush won the state despite receiving less than 50% of the total vote because third-party progressive candidate Ralph Nader drained vital votes from Al Gore. Under the John Rozean ABC mathematical model of Florida 2000, when two ideologically adjacent candidates fracture a single base, a united minority can easily defeat a divided majority.

Historically, jurisdictions attempted to solve this issue through separate runoff elections held weeks later. However, delayed runoffs introduce severe civic and budgetary costs. Voter participation between the general election and a runoff typically plummets by 40%, and local governments must spend millions of dollars in taxpayer funds to restaff and operate empty polling locations.


Alaska’s ranked-choice voting model replaces that delayed process with an instant runoff conducted on the original ballot:

  • Simultaneous Collection: Voters express backup preferences upfront by ranking candidates in order of preference (1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th).

  • Sequential Elimination: If no candidate attains a majority of first-choice votes, the candidate with the fewest votes is eliminated.

  • Instant Redistribution: The ballots cast for that eliminated candidate transfer automatically to whoever each voter marked as their next active choice.

  • Consolidation of the Majority: Rather than punishing voters for backing minor contenders, the system pools secondary preferences until a candidate achieves an undeniable mathematical majority at peak voter turnout.


In short, ranked-choice voting was engineered specifically to solve the exact problem Trump is complaining about. If minor candidates were indeed acting as inadvertent spoilers against an incumbent with majority backing, RCV would naturally transfer their backup support to that incumbent.


4. Elimination Hypothesis: Tabulating Second Choices in Alaska

Because Alaska utilizes an instant-runoff process, ballots do not transfer en masse to any single candidate. Instead, they reallocate according to cast vote records analyzed by FairVote and The New York Times. The sequential tabulation proceeds through two distinct rounds:


Round 1: Elimination of Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. (4,652 Votes)

With the lowest vote tally among all contenders (~1.6%), undeclared candidate Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. is eliminated first.

Both Donald Trump and the U.S. Department of Justice suggested in public statements and legal challenges that the presence of a second candidate named Sullivan on the ballot created widespread voter confusion, inadvertently siphoning votes from the incumbent. However, cast vote records thoroughly debunk this thesis:

  • Peltola Favored as Second Choice: A plurality of Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.’s voters—approximately 34% (~1,582 ballots)—listed Democrat Mary Peltola as their second choice.

  • Sen. Sullivan Received Fewer Transfers: Only approximately 23% (~1,070 ballots) ranked incumbent Sen. Dan S. Sullivan second.

  • Ballot Exhaustion and Third Choices: The remaining ~43% (~2,000 ballots) either exhausted by leaving subsequent ranks blank or ranked Gerald L. Heikes.


Cross-tabulations against concurrent gubernatorial ballots show that voters who backed Sullivan Jr. were overwhelmingly Democratic-leaning citizens executing a deliberate protest vote, rather than confused Republicans. Consequently, rather than narrowing the incumbent's deficit, Round 1 expands Mary Peltola’s lead by an estimated 512 net votes.


Round 2: Elimination of Gerald L. Heikes (6,002 Votes)

Following the reallocation of Sullivan Jr.'s ballots, Republican Gerald L. Heikes occupies last place among active contenders (~2.1%) and is eliminated next.

FairVote’s analysis of preliminary cast vote records illustrates a completely different transfer profile for Heikes:

  • Strong Republican Second-Choice Preference: Among Heikes voters who ranked a frontrunner, incumbent Sen. Dan S. Sullivan was favored by more than two-to-one, capturing approximately 41% to 42% of Heikes’ ballots (~2,461 to 2,521 votes).

  • Cross-Over to Peltola: Mary Peltola captured approximately 18% of Heikes’ second choices (~1,080 votes).

  • High Rate of "Bullet Voting": Critically, approximately 40% to 41% of Heikes’ supporters (~2,401 to 2,461 ballots) chose to "bullet vote"—ranking Heikes and leaving all other candidate columns blank. These ballots immediately exhaust and drop out of the final tabulation.


5. Projected Final Tabulation and Outcome

When the transfers from both elimination rounds are combined, the minor-candidate preferences largely offset one another, producing only a negligible net movement toward the incumbent Sen. Dan S. Sullivan:

Candidate

First-Choice Baseline

Transfers from Sullivan Jr.

Transfers from Heikes

Projected Final Total

Projected Final Share

Mary Peltola (D)

140,637

+1,582

+1,080

~143,299

~51.9%

Dan S. Sullivan (R, Inc.)

129,424

+1,070

+2,491

~132,985

~48.1%

Exhausted / Inactive Ballots

—

~2,000

~2,431

~4,431

—

Active Continuing Ballots

280,715

—

—

~276,284

100.0%

  • Net Tabulation Shift: Across both rounds, incumbent Sen. Dan S. Sullivan gains approximately 3,561 transfer votes, while Mary Peltola gains approximately 2,662 transfer votes. This yields a net gain of just 899 votes for the incumbent—shifting the overall margin by approximately 0.2 percentage points.

  • Final Margin: Mary Peltola’s final margin of victory is projected at ~10,314 votes, securing an outright majority of all continuing ballots.


6. Synthesis: Why the "Stolen by Spoilers" Myth Fails

The empirical and mathematical realities of the Alaska Senate election decisively refute the narrative that "fake candidates" or spoiler dynamics altered the outcome:

  1. The Plurality Test: Mary Peltola did not merely lead a fractured field; her raw first-choice vote total exceeds the combined sum of all three challengers by 559 votes.

  2. The Intentionality of Backup Choices: The presumption that third-party or independent voters belong to an incumbent by default ignores the deliberate choices expressed on actual ballots. Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.’s voters favored Peltola over the incumbent, while more than 4,400 minor-candidate voters intentionally refused to endorse either frontrunner.

  3. The Structural Safeguard: Ranked-choice voting did not obscure the majority’s will—it verified it. By testing voters' backup choices directly, the instant-runoff process confirms that Mary Peltola commands majority support among Alaska voters.


Want to dive deeper into ranked-choice voting and the spoiler effect?

For a quick, visual guide to how these systems work in practice, check out these two short videos:

  1. Runoffs vs. Instant-Runoff: Learn how ranked-choice voting replaces expensive, low-turnout secondary elections with an instant runoff on the original ballot in “The $30M Voting Glitch: Runoffs vs. Instant-Runoff.”

  2. The Spoiler Effect Explained: See how the math of the 2000 Florida presidential race explains vote-splitting—and how ranked-choice voting solves it—in “Why the Left Always Loses: The Math of Florida 2000.”

  3. Classroom Deep Dive: See instructor John Rozean walk his students at Stephens College in Columbia, Missouri through the mathematical trade-offs between standard Plurality, Ranked-Choice (Instant Runoff), and the Borda Count in “Voting Methods Compared: Plurality, Ranked-Choice (Instant Runoff), and Borda Count.”






 
 
 

Comments


Post: Blog2_Post
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

©2021 by full of doubt. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page